Monthly Archives: June 2012

A Prayer for Owen Meany

I must admit that periodically felt disengaged from this book because I was unfamiliar with many important issues it covered. I don’t know much about the Vietnam War or American politics. I didn’t know the difference between different Christian denominations. I’m not interested in religion and I have to admit to regarding a belief in God as a weakness.

In contrast to the ‘heavy’ stuff there are some very funny scenes in the book which made me guffaw. There are poignant times too; Owen genuinely moved me. He was such a good friend to Johnny. Like me, he is tiny but very serious. Unlike me, he has the power to manipulate. I couldn’t find much likeable about the narrator but I did identify with Johnny’s indecision and metaphorical impotence. I thought that the development of characters and their relationships through the years are very well done. The unsolved mysteries kept me interested and reading on even when it felt like hard work. Towards the beginning especially I became frustrated by events and ranting that didn’t seem to be of any significance.

There were some nuggets of wisdom in the book, including my favourite: ‘IF YOU@RE LUCKY ENOUGH TO FIND A WAY OF LIFE YOU LOVE, YOU HAVE TO FIND THE COURAGE TO LIVE IT.’

The ending is truly magnificent. It’s definitely worth keeping going through the 600-odd pages to reach it. I sobbed as Owen’s fate unfolded. Much that is unexplained earlier finally falls into place. The revealed significances are like a tidal wave.

After I’d finished the book I knew there was more to it that I’d taken in on the first reading. I found some excellent chapter summaries and analysis on the SparkNotes website.

(24th in 2012)

One Good Turn

This is a decent read, addictive as claimed on the jacket, and kept me guessing. Unlike how I felt about Case Histories (the first book in the Jackson Brodie series) I was satisfied with how all the endings were tied up. I felt that some parts of the plot were a little cliched though, the prime example of which was the powerful businessman employing a dominatrix. But I do love how KA brings her characters to life by devoting long passages to their thoughts which I get lost in. I think that’s the best aspect of her writing. A special mention has to go to the bit where someone has to explain to his brother that there has been mix-up and he is not dead as previously reported. I cried with laughter. Twice.

The TV series of the Jackson Brodie novels is called Case Histories and is currently being shown on BBC HD. I thought I would read the books before watching their dramatisations. The books Case Histories, One Good Turn and When Will There Be Good News? have each been made into two part dramatisations. I thought the Case Histories episodes looked good (pretty scenes of Edinburgh, good looking cast and mostly decent casting) but the translation to screen didn’t work for me; it all felt very disjointed. I watched only the second part of One Good Turn (annoyingly I mistakenly deleted the recording of the first part) and felt the same. I’m now debating whether I should try watching When Will There Be Good News? before reading the book, to see whether I’ll enjoy the programmes more if I don’t know anything about the plot beforehand.

(23rd in 2012)

What Was Lost

This is the first book I’ve read with my reading group. I liked it a lot. It is very spooky and feels very close to home which I find to be a good combination. It’s written by someone very close to my age who grew up in the Midlands so I understood all her cultural references. Not only that but the shopping centre featured is based on the Merry Hill centre. I couldn’t find much to criticize in this at all. It’s a multi-faceted book, with both hilarious and poignant moments. It has a cracking mystery running through it and contains a thoughtful depiction of modern life.

(22nd in 2012)